Health care is expensive—and confusing. As premiums and deductibles climb, many people are exploring alternatives to traditional health insurance. One option gaining popularity is a health sharing plan.
But what exactly is a health sharing plan? And how does it differ from standard health insurance?
Here’s a clear breakdown of both options so you can decide what’s right for you.
What Is Traditional Health Insurance?
Health insurance is a regulated product that helps cover medical costs. It’s offered by private companies, employers, or government programs like Medicare and Medicaid.
Key Features of Health Insurance
-
Monthly premiums: You pay these even if you don’t use services.
-
Deductibles: The amount you pay out-of-pocket before coverage kicks in.
-
Copays and coinsurance: Shared costs after meeting the deductible.
-
Provider networks: Plans may limit where you can go for care.
-
Legal protection: Must follow ACA (Affordable Care Act) rules.
Health insurance is designed to be predictable and structured—even if it sometimes feels costly.
What Is a Health Sharing Plan?
Health sharing plans are cooperative programs where members pool money to help each other with medical expenses. They’re often organized around shared religious or ethical beliefs.
Key Features of Health Sharing Plans
-
Monthly “sharing” amounts: Similar to premiums but not legally binding.
-
Member responsibility: Like a deductible, you pay a certain amount first.
-
Voluntary reimbursement: Payments aren’t guaranteed, unlike insurance.
-
Faith or lifestyle criteria: Most require a shared belief system or behavior standards.
-
No ACA compliance: Not required to cover preexisting conditions or preventive care.
These programs promote community responsibility—but they are not insurance in the legal sense.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Health Insurance | Health Sharing Plan |
|---|---|---|
| Regulated by law | Yes (ACA compliant) | No |
| Guarantees payment | Yes | No |
| Covers preexisting conditions | Required | Often not covered |
| Preventive care coverage | Required | Not guaranteed |
| Monthly cost | Premiums vary by plan | Often lower than insurance premiums |
| Network restrictions | Varies (HMO, PPO, etc.) | Often allows any provider |
| Tax benefits | Yes (can use HSA/FSA) | Sometimes (limited with HSA use) |
| Religious/lifestyle requirement | No | Usually required |
Pros and Cons of Each Option
Traditional Health Insurance
Pros:
-
Legal protections
-
Comprehensive coverage
-
Includes preventive and mental health care
-
Meets ACA mandates
Cons:
-
Higher monthly costs
-
Limited networks in some plans
-
Can be complex to understand
Health Sharing Plans
Pros:
-
Lower monthly costs
-
Flexibility in choosing providers
-
Sense of community
Cons:
-
No guarantee of coverage
-
May exclude certain conditions or treatments
-
Not ideal for people with ongoing health needs
Who Might Consider a Health Sharing Plan?
-
People in good health looking for basic coverage
-
Self-employed individuals without employer insurance
-
Those aligned with the plan’s faith or ethical values
-
Individuals seeking a lower-cost alternative to ACA plans
Important Caveats with Health Sharing
It’s essential to understand what a health sharing plan won’t do:
-
It may deny reimbursement for care it deems non-compliant with its beliefs.
-
It does not fulfill ACA mandates, so you won’t have legal protections.
-
In a medical emergency or with a serious illness, you could face major out-of-pocket costs.
Always read the fine print and ask questions before joining.
Real-World Example: Cost Comparison
| Scenario | Health Insurance Plan | Health Sharing Plan |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $550 | $200–$350 |
| Annual Deductible | $2,500 | $1,000–$5,000 member share |
| Preventive Care | Covered | Varies, often excluded |
| ER Visit Reimbursement | Guaranteed (after deductible) | Not guaranteed, case-by-case |
These numbers vary widely, but the cost difference is clear. So is the trade-off in certainty and coverage.
How to Choose the Right Option
Ask yourself:
-
Do I need guaranteed coverage for chronic conditions?
-
Am I okay with some uncertainty in how costs are handled?
-
Do I qualify for subsidies on the ACA marketplace?
-
Do I want my coverage to align with specific values or beliefs?
Your answers will point you toward the plan that best fits your budget and health needs.
Wrapping Up: Understanding the Trade-Off
Health sharing plans and traditional health insurance are built on very different foundations. One offers regulated security, the other offers community-based savings—but with more risk.
If you’re healthy and value flexibility, health sharing might appeal. But if you want legal protections and comprehensive care, traditional insurance is likely the safer bet.
Ultimately, the best choice comes down to your health needs, risk tolerance, and values. Just make sure you fully understand what you’re signing up for—especially when your health and finances are on the line.